News Introduction Editorial Board Submission Table of Contents Table of Contents E-Journals Search
Humanitas Taiwanica, No. 97
Item
Title
Author

1

Quandaries between the Issues of Worldliness and the Profoundness of Confucius – Re-visiting the Conception of Zhuangzi’s “Knowing Confucius” from “In the World of Men,” the Zhuangzi

    This article revisits the topic “Zhuangzi Honoring Confucius” based on investigating the chapter “In the World of Men” from the Zhuangzi. On the one hand, by analyzing the paragraphs whereby “Confucius” is featured as the main character, this paper examines the notions that Zhuangzi wishes to explore and construct by means of the “Confucius” imagery. On the other hand, the paper compares and contrasts the “Confucius” imagery and Zhuangzi’s ideas to contemplate Zhuangzi’s reasons for inserting such imagery in his own narrative, and to discern the ideological similarities and differences between Zhuangzi and Confucius. There are two types of “Confucius” imageries featured in the Zhuangzi a person comprehending Taoism and a person pursuing achievements. Through juxtaposing the fictional and historical Confucius imageries, this paper argues that the intersection of both types of imageries represents Zhuangzi’s acceptance and transcendence of Confucius ideology. Hence, under such conflicting contexts, it is inadequate to claim that Zhuanzi either “deprecates Confucius,” by repudiating all his praises for Confusious, or “honors Confucius,” by reverting all his criticisms about Confucius. Therefore, to encompass both aspects of “honoring” and “deprecating,” this paper adopts instead the position of “comprehending Confucius.”

Chen, Yong-han

2

Pursuing Promising and Satisfactory Ideal at the Yuan Kuang Monastery: A Study of Master Benji’s Poetry during his Early Period of Residency in Taiwan

    Master Benji (1884-1968), originally named Long Can, was born in Tongcheng, Anhui. He became a monk in Taiwan and completed multiple works, including The Poetry of Huaibo Mountain House (懷柏山房吟草). In 1949, sixty-six-year-old Lung Can sojourned in Taiwan because of the Chinese Civil War. During his stay, he followed Master Miaoguo in the Zhongli Yuan Guang Monastery, and entered monastic life under the Dharma name Benji after receiving ordination from Master Nanting. Although Master Benji traveled extensively during his lifetime, he mainly resided at Huaibo Mountain House (懷柏山房), Yuan Guang Monastery before 1957. Through his constant chantings of the lines from Promising and Satisfactory Spirit of Yaodi (光圓藥地靈), it signals that Master Benji shared a spiritual commitment with Monk Yaodi (Fang Yi-zhi), who also came from Master Benji’s hometown. Thus, at the Yuan Kuang Monastery, he formed the Kuang Yuan (promising and satisfactory) Ideal, which intimated his yearning for the restoration of the nation. Additionally, during his lifetime at the Yuan Guang Monastery, Master Benji often versed poetry with literati, such as Xue Yi-song, Yang Yi-feng, Yu Jing-tang and Yu You-ren, who visited Taiwan. These collaborative poems reflected the collective sentiments of the poets. Although at the Yuan Guang Monastery he formed an inseparable bond with Taiwan, Master Benji, being “an Old Longmian Wanderer,” still yearned to return to his homeland. As he continued his monastery life to fulfill Buddhism, his pursuit of the Kuan Yuan Ideal still awaited the promised satisfatory completeness.
Hsieh, Ming-yang

3

The Counter-Enlightenment Connection between China and Japan: Cai Yuanpei’s Reception of Inoue Enryō’s Works


    This paper draws attention to Cai Yuanpei’s translations of Inoue Enryō’s (1858-1919) works, showing how Western Counter- Enlightenment thoughts are propagated and locally transfigured in East-Asia. Moreover, this study reflects how Cai acts initiatively by examining his selection and reflection processes in his transcultral translation endeavors. From 1900 to 1906, Cai derived the dialectic of Enlightenment from editing and translating Inoue’s works, e.g., “Protection of Country through Buddhism,” and Lectures on Mystery Studies. By analyzing several aspects of Inoue’s works, including the ideas of Protection of Country through Buddhism, affect/intellect religion, Mystery Studies and dialetics on rationality, and aesthetics appreciation, the paper discusses how such concepts directly and/or potentially inspire Cai. In addition, a comparison of Inoue’s Mystery Studies and Cai’s idea of “Replacing Religion with an Aesthetics Education” further reveals the mechanisms behind Cai’s philosophical development. The aim of this paper is to argue that Inoue’s notion of Enlightenment in religion and Cai’s Enlightenment Sentimentality are closely related. As such, their relatedness represents a connection of Counter-Enlightenment between China and Japan, from which both figures contribute to the re-contextualization of transcultural exchange of thoughts in the late Qing and early Republican China.
Yau, Kevin Ting-kit

4

On Zeng Tian-zong’s Critique of Husserl’s “Intentional Correlates”

    Zeng Tian-zong (1910-2007) is one of the representatives of Taiwanese philosophy from the period of Japanese rule. Through his concept of “Quasi-Truth-in-itself,” which is one of Zeng’s main contributions to philosophy, he criticizes the basic form of idealism. In response to Husserl's “phenomenological reduction,” he proposes the idea of “alethiological reduction” as the main basis for “pure philosophy” in his study of alethiology. This paper examines Zeng’s critique of Husserl's phenomenology, especially of Husserl's “intentional correlates,” which are pertinent to the “sense” (Sinn) and “object” (Gegenstand) in intentional acts. As the discussion of “intentional correlates” has been a classic and long-running dispute among the “Husserl scholars,” this paper further appends the complications of phenomenology to A. Gurwitsch’s, Dagfinn Føllesdal’s and R. Bernet’s respective interpretations in order to highlight Zeng Tian-zong’s robust contribution to philosophy.
Huang, Wen-hong

5

The Borderline between the Human and the Calligraphy, and the Distinction between the Fundamentals and the Ancillaries: Techniques and Human Limits in Zhao Yi’s Against Cursive Calligraphy

    Written during the Eastern Han period, Against Cursive Calligraphy, being the very first Chinese essay on calligraphy, is the earliest documented criticism of cursive calligraphy. To affirm their aesthetic awareness, later scholars have defended the arts by accusing Against Cursive Calligraphy of imposing a moral framework, which privileges practicality over aesthetics, on cursive calligraphy. Nevertheless, this article argues that Against Cursive Calligraphy should not be understood as a denounciation of calligraphy due to a lack of aesthetic awareness. Rather, it should be interpreted reflectively based on the examination of pan-aesthetic cultural phenomen and the division of disciplines. In this light, Against Cursive Calligraphy is indeed ahead of its time due to its accentuation of the cursive’s cultural development during the budding aesthetic progession of calligraphy. According to Against Cursive Calligraphy, the birth of art originates from techniques without traces of their origin, and the birth of techniques originates from humans who leave their origins behind. Hence, this article argues that the birth of art is not directly linked to human awareness, but is connected to the absence of humanity. Furthermore, the development of cursive calligraphy indicates how techniques challenged the human limits and forced people to reassess and determine their future.
Shen, Yu-chang
Editing Committee Office of Humanitas Taiwanica,
College of Liberal Arts, National Taiwan University
No. 1, Sec. 4, Roosevelt Road, Taipei, 106319 Taiwan Tel: +886-2-33663820   Fax: +886-2-23632164   E-mail:
bcla@ntu.edu.tw