News Introduction Editorial Board Submission Table of Contents Table of Contents E-Journals Search
Humanitas Taiwanica, No. 80
Item
Title
Author

1

"On Narrative and Genre in Pre-Qin Historiographical Documents: “The Fall of the Luan Clan of Jin” as an Example "


   This paper attempts to analyze how “the fall of the Luan clan” of the Jin state (晉「欒氏之滅」) is interpreted in various historiographical documents in pre-Qin and early Han periods, and discusses the association between the genre and the narrator’s viewpoint and intention of those particular documents.
The paper compares the differences in narrative— including aspects of plot, character image, theme, and viewpoint—between the Zuo Commentary and Sayings of the States, indicating that the two books, though only slightly different in plot, represent “realities” of diverse views. It discusses in what way the content is associated with the genre in the narrative of the pre-Qin and early Han historiographical texts, both archaeological findings and textual records, with particular emphasis on “The Chronicles” in Tsinghua Bamboo Slips II. By comparing the Spring and Autumn Annals, the Zuo Commentary, Sayings of the States, Records of the Grand Historian, and “The Chronicles” , the paper points out that “The Chronicles” is of a different genre from the Spring and Autumn Annals. The paper ends by focusing on pre-Qin and early Han historiographical documents regarding “the Fall of the Luan clan,” such as the Gongyang Commentary, Guliang Commentary, The Annals of Lu Buwei, Shizi, etc. By illustrating the differences in genre among the books aforementioned, the present study expects to explain the relationship between narrative and genre in historiographical texts from pre-Qin to early Han periods.

Lee, Long-shien

2

The Construction of the "Zhengyu" Theory in Zhongyuan yin yun

   Zhou Deqing's (1277-1365) Zhongyuan yin yun annotates that his book serves as “a model for zhengyu and a rectification of bianya.” Based on this statement, this article will explore his Rules for Composing the Traditional Northern Opera with Correct Sounds in the book. In addition, according to Zhou's understanding of ""entering tones are situated between breathing and speaking,” the author will investigate Zhou's construction of zhengyu theory.
This article is divided into four sections. After an introduction in section one, section two explicates the linguistic background and meaning of the above mentioned statement. This statement signifies that the pronunciation in Zhou’s book was deemed standard in the Central Plains, rectifying the disadvantages of various dialects, and differentiating divergences among Guang yun and various types of operas in Chinese dialects. Section three compares the following rhyming phenomena: level tones divided into voiceless and voiced level tones, entering tones recategorized into level, rising, and departing tones, and a lack of closed entering tones and rhyming. Section four analyzes the subject dialects that Zhou rectified, especially the Wu dialect in Song-Yuan southern drama.
Grounded in the differences between Zhongyuan yin yun and Guang yun, Zhou fulfilled the objective of “a model for zhengyu” and brought the aim of “a rectification of bianya” to a successful conclusion through the comparison of central pronunciation with the Wu and other dialects. Not completely agreeing with what Guang yun argues, he viewed dialects as having deficiencies and meanwhile accepted them as pronunciation in common practices. His goal of composing Zhongyuan yin yun was to historicize the changes of sounds and therefore normalize pronunciation for traditional Chinese opera.
Li, Huei-mian

3

Exploring the Aesthetics of Visual Images Penetrating Through Curtains in The Complete Collection of Ci from Song


   One of the earliest items used to separate the indoor and outdoor areas in traditional Chinese architectures, curtains could create the far-reaching tranquility and a peaceful atmosphere when hung. In addition to protecting and respecting personal privacy, hanging curtains could also add the aesthetics of visual images. Thus, not only could large public spaces or private spaces be separated by them, but also a variety of different artistic effects could be created. This paper looks at how curtains are used in The Complete Collection of Ci from Song, specifically analyzing the following two aspects: 1) examining visual images and aesthetics when the moonlight, ornamentals, swallows, and so on are depicted penetrating through hanging curtains and entering indoor spaces, and 2) enumerating the variety of lights and shadows that were created by the sunlight or moonlight penetrating through hanging curtains.
Huang, Shu-cheng

4

An Investigation of the Yi Mansion Library: With Emphasis on the Newly-found The Catalog of Books Displayed in Ying Tang

   The Yi Mansion Library is regarded as one of the most important and largest collection of books in the Qing dynasty and even throughout the history of private libraries in China. However, it has not been given the attention it deserves.
The academic field has long harbored misconceptions on the sources, circulation, and size of the library, as well as the time the Catalog of the Yi Mansion Library was compiled, the courtesy names of the masters of Yi Mansion, etc. (especially regarding the fact that many books came from Xu Qianxue and Ji Zhenyi’s old collections). Furthermore, the Anle Tang of the Yi Mansion is sometimes mistaken for Emperor Qianlong’s Mingshan Tang or Leshan Tang. With the help the newly-found book The Catalog of Books Displayed in Ying Tang in Yi Mansion and other new materials, this essay sets forth some new ideas on different aspects of the Yi Mansion Library by surveying hundreds of books from the library currently found in more than twenty libraries throughout the world and investigating it in a systematic way.
Hou, Yin-guo

5

An Analysis of the Claim that 'Mental Karma is the Most Significant' in Buddhism

    This paper is an investigation of the claim in Buddhism that ‘mental action (manaskarman) is the most reprehensible for the performance of evil action.’ There are five parts to the analysis: Firstly, I analyze the chapter in the agama sutra where the claim first appears, so as to illuminate the basic view substantiating the claim that ‘mental karma is the most significant (of the three karmas)’. Secondly, I analyze arguments for and against this claim given in the Satyasiddhi??stra, pointing out that the emphasis on ‘mental karma’ is to stress the ‘mind as the root of everything.’ All dharmas have mind as their basic premise onto which follows the formation of good or bad karma. Thirdly, I point out that the emphasis on ‘mental karma’ stems from the view that, unlike actions of body and speech, mental processes are karmic processes in themselves. This is illustrated by the close connection between manas, cetana, sa?sk?ra, and karma. This does not however imply that actions of body and speech are unimportant. On the contrary, body and speech facilitate the formation of karma, expanding its effects and reinforcing the depth and strength of the agent's intention. Fourthly, the emphasis on ‘mental karma’ functions as an important criterion for judgments of good/evil and right/wrong, which carries its own ethical implications worthy of consideration. Towards the end of this section, I offer a preliminary reflection on the possible limitations of the claim. Lastly, I suggest that the emphasis on ‘mental karma’ not only challenges the philosophical tradition of ancient India, but further allows for reflection and dialogue within the study of contemporary ethics and philosophy. As such, further research on this topic is both meaningful and worthy of pursuit.
Lin, Chien-te
Editing Committee Office of Humanitas Taiwanica,
College of Liberal Arts, National Taiwan University
No. 1, Sec. 4, Roosevelt Road, Taipei, 106319 Taiwan Tel: +886-2-33663820   Fax: +886-2-23632164   E-mail:
bcla@ntu.edu.tw