News Introduction Editorial Board Submission Table of Contents Table of Contents E-Journals Search
Humanitas Taiwanica, No. 75
Item
Title
Author

1

A New Investigation of “Si/Si” and “Shi” in the Chu Bamboo Slips and Silk Manuscripts


This article investigates the distribution of three characters (si), (si) and (shi) in the Chu slips and silk manuscripts, and analyzes their meanings and grammatical function in the texts to make clear the usage of “si/si” and its relationship with “shi.” The conclusion is that some “si/si” in the Chu slips and silk manuscripts should be interpreted as the causative verb “shi” instead of “si,” which means “to think.” Writing the causative verb “shi” with the formation of “si/si” was a distinctive tradition of Chu people in the middle to later period of Warring States. According to documents handed down for generations, this tradition was confined to the state of Chu in the middle to later period of Warring State and not found in documents from a later period or other region. The confusion between the usages of “si” and “shi” in the Chu slips and silk manuscripts is due to transcriptions of the Chu copyists. Finally, this article analyzes the meaning and usage of “si/si” in the Chu divination texts and gives explanation to the related paragraphs.

Wu, Hsueh-ju

2

Examination Essays and the Culture of Examination in the Sung

With the adoption of the civil service examination system and the spread of printing technology in the Sung, the quantity of books increased dramatically. Among numerous books in the market, one genre stands out—examination essays (shiwen). The significances of examination essays are multiple. First, the government published essays that were successful in the civil service examinations, implying they are “model essays.” Second, commercial book printers, sometimes illegally, circulating them reveals the profitability of this genre. Third, that examinees purchased these “model essays” shows how eager they vied to pass the examinations. Fourth, by mid- and late Southern Sung, commercial printers asked literati or scholar-officials to compile examination essays, using their publicity to promote the sale. Fifth, personal exam essays in book form also appeared. They desired to increase their publicity so that they would be known by the examiners, and would be able to pass the exams. This paper attempts to analyze the compilation and circulation of examination essays in the hope of understanding the relationship between the civil service examinations and the production of books, as well as their significances in Sung society.
Liu, Hsiang-kwang

3

Wang Zhi’s Rethinking of Qing and Ming Commentary on Zhengmeng: As Seen from Three Meanings of “The Great Void”


Zheng meng chu yi (The Original Meaning of Zheng meng) contains the most comprehensive collection of commentary on Zheng meng. Its author, Wang Zhi, not only preserved important research on Zheng meng from the Ming and Qing dynasties, he also attempted to sidestep the framework of interpretation put in place by Zhu Xi and thus be able to reevaluate the philosophical issues current at the time Zhang Zai wrote his work. As such, it is an invaluable tool for later scholars researching Zheng meng. Because Wang Zhi pointed out that the key to understanding Zheng meng is the concept of “the Great Void,” this paper will explore it through three sections: first, the implications of the three different meanings of “the Great Void will be delineated and the way they are interrelated discussed. Second, Wang Zhi’s rethinking of Ming and Qing commentary will be appraised based on the three meanings of “the Great Void.” Lastly, Wang Zhi’s use of these three meanings in refuting criticism by Yi Chuan and Zhu Xi will be looked at, which effectively provides a new means of interpretation different from the Cheng Yi or Zhu Xi.
Chen, Cheng-yang

4

Toward an Aesthetic Genealogy of The Dream of the Red Chamber and Mid-Late Tang Poetry

Studies on the poetry of The Dream of the Red Chamber should carefully distinguish between “poetics” and “poetry”: while the novel claims high Tang poetry, which emphasizes gediao 格調 as ideal models, in practice it adopts themes of mid-late Tang poetry, which scarifies elegance for rich variations and emphasizes xingling 性靈. This paper focuses on the poetic practice in The Dream of the Red Chamber, covering aesthetic paradigms through style trends and image formations, to adoption and transformation of previous poetic works. Through detailed analysis it is clear that The Dream of the Red Chamber in practice uses mid-late Tang poetry as its aspiration and source. Lastly, I discuss the psychological similarity between the poets of mid-late Tang and the characters in the novel to further illuminate the narrative background and the deep motivation of The Dream of the Red Chamber.
Ou, Li-chuan

5

The Practices of Ritual of Zhu Shunshui and Mitohan in Edo Period

Zhu Shunshui’s (1600-1682) direct or indirect contact with scholars of the Zhu Xi school, the Yangming school or even the Old Text school in the early Tokugawa period had a great influence on the development of Confucianism in Japan. Through a comprehensive review of Zhu Shunshui’s essays, correspondences and many writings from his disciples, it was found that he often expressed his viewpoints to Japanese government officials and scholars. Zhu Shunshui stayed in Nagasaki, Edo, and Mito. Nevertheless, his promotion of Confucianism can be traced from Kashima (modern Saga), to Yanagawa (modern Fukuoka) to Kaga (modern Ishikawa) around the Sea of Japan—all places he had never been.
This paper is focused on the study of (1) the development of a broad-ranging Confucianism in the early Tokugawa period and (2) the perspective of Zhu Shunshui and the development of Mito Confucianism, and the fundamental principles of Confucianism—the concepts of ceremonial rites, xing jiaoyu xing lizhi (promote education, perform rituals), and yang junde qin xianshi (develop a sovereign virtue, get close to virtuous gentlemen) between Zhu Shunshui and Tokugawa Mitukuni (1628-1700) and its impact on the practices of rites advocated by Seignior Mito.
Shyu, Shing-ching

6

Types and Connotations of Christian Discussion on Bushido in the Meiji Period

Focusing on the theme “Christian discussion on Bushido,” this article analyzes types and strategies of integration between the targets of Christianity and Bushido. The analysis specifically addresses the Christians Ebina Danjo, Uemura Masahisa, Nitobe Inaz? and Uchimura Kanzo, the symbolic figures of a generation spanning the two eras of Late Tokugawa Shogunate and the Meiji Restoration. The second portion of this study discusses their background, showing that, they are undoubtedly sincere believers in Christianity and its universalism in the early Meiji period, while being samurais from older domains who opposed the new Meiji government. In the third section, the author classifies the Christians’ discussion of Bushido into four types—evolutional, jointed, assimilative, and parental—based on their different viewpoints and characteristics. Conclusively, these Christians intentionally overlooked historical context in their discussion on Bushido ethics and the problem that Christians may involve too much personal emotion in religion. At the same time, they were often torn by the tension between nationalism and internationalism.

Chang, Kun-Chiang

7

On the Aesthetical Inclination in Contemporary Japanese Philosophy: An Explication According to Nakamura's Theory of Common Sense


My primary concern in this paper is to explicate the meaning of the aesthetical (perceptual) inclination in contemporary Japanese philosophy. I will put my focal point on the discussion of Nakamura Yujiro's characterization of common sense, which is also a key concept in his philosophy. In the first section I discuss two main trends in contemporary Japanese philosophy in Hamada's analysis. In section two I begin with Nakamura's explication of the two basic meanings of common sense. Common sense is first according to Aristotle the sense which integrates five senses. And second, something derived basically from Cicero, it can also be thought of as a sense which people share in a common society. Next in section three, I turn to Blankenburg's and Kimura Bin's analysis of the two different kinds of mental disorders, hebephrenic schizophrenia and depersonalization disorder. They both treat these mental disorders as different ineffectiveness in common sense. I emphasize Nakamura's interpretation of Kimura Bin's theory concerning hebephrenic schizophrenia. Some critical positions and reflections I take against Nakamura's conception of common sense are also expressed in section four. It is my view that Nakamura has interpreted common sense as a practical wisdom (phronesis) which grasps the whole circumstance. In this section I also try to expound some possible horizons that are opened by contemporary Japanese aesthetics.
Huang, Wen-hong
Editing Committee Office of Humanitas Taiwanica,
College of Liberal Arts, National Taiwan University
No. 1, Sec. 4, Roosevelt Road, Taipei, 106319 Taiwan Tel: +886-2-33663820   Fax: +886-2-23632164   E-mail:
bcla@ntu.edu.tw