News Introduction Editorial Board Submission Table of Contents Table of Contents E-Journals Search
Humanitas Taiwanica, No. 71
Item
Title
Author

1

From Talent Self-Being to Daoist Nature Self-Being: The Rise and Development of the Daoist Self-Being Theory from the Six Dynasties to Early Tang


This paper explores the context of the rise and development of the Daoist self-being theory from the Six Dynasties to early Tang. Following the rise of the transcendentalist self-being theory in the Wei and Jin dynasties, the term “self-being” was frequently used in many Daoist scriptures. While the early Daoist self-being theory seemed rather broad in is various applications, it was founded in the concept of “self-being” and theoretically based on the talent theory. Hence, it can also be referred to as talent self-being theory. The focus of the talent self-being theory is on explaining the grand source of all things on earth. However, in terms of personal cultivation, the theory leads to fatalism.
Later, the term “self-being” was used to explain the character and status of the Daoist nature. Chong Xuan Daoism used the term to identity of a thing-in-itself. This theory can be called the nature self-being theory. The establishment of this theory successfully rebutted Buddhist criticism of the inability of mortals to become saints, a tenet held by both Confucians and Daoists. It also later provided a theoretical foundation for the establishment of the personal cultivation theory of Neo-Confucians.
Lin, Yung-sheng

2

On Ding Ruoyong’s Tan Gong Zheng Wu

The Korean scholar Chong Yagyong (a.k.a. Chong Tasan, 1762-1836) is a eminent master of the practical learning school of thought during the late part of the Joseon dynasty. In his work on rituals, Tan Gong Zhen Wu, he corrects 172 mistakes in various annotations of “Tan Gong.” The book contains a wide range of references to Chinese classics and quotes from a plethora of classical scholars. However, Chong expresses his discontent toward Chinese scholars with incisive criticisms, a rare occurrence in scholarly circles at the time. Whether these claims are founded or perceived is for us of later generations to determine.
In reading Tan Gong Zhen Wu, it is clear that some of Chong’s criticisms are reasonable, yet others are subject to his personal judgment and fallacious reasoning. A few contain a mixture of the two. In some passages, his remarks show that he misread the text in question. All in all, they reveal a subjective and trenchant response to many misunderstood passages.
Chong’s views are influenced, in part, by Ao Jigong and his work Yi Li Ji Shuo, which was popular in Korean academic circle at the time. Another reason was that many important works on the classics in China never made it to Korea. This is especially apparent in terms of his explanations of the funeral ceremony from the viewpoint that “children cannot bear to have their parent’s die.”
Yeh,Kuo-liang

3

The Foundation of the Innate Goodness of Human Nature: An Analysis of the First Six Chapters of “Gaozi” in the Mencius in Relation to the Problem of Human Nature


Mencius’ contribution to the debate on human nature is that he advocated that human nature is innately good. This viewpoint is the keystone to a positive appraisal of human existence. But since there are so many conflicts and evils in life, how can Mencius verify this view? Such a standpoint is far more difficult to defend than other theories on human nature. This paper is an analysis of the problem through a rereading of the first six chapters of “Gaozi” in the Mencius. These six chapters are interconnected in their inferences and discuss the important issues regarding this problem. The sequence is as follows: the basis for a theory on human nature, the reasons for the goodness of man and also their evilness, the independency of human nature, the problem of whether human nature or the conscious mind is the true essence of man, human nature and its application in reality, and the explanation of human nature itself as well as the Way of human nature. With such a structure, we can conclude that the view of Mencius on human nature is more complete and profound than all other theories.
Chien, Liang-ju

4

The Formation of the Concessive Conditionals Ji, Bian and Jiu

This paper explores the formation of the concessive conditional conjunctions ji, bian and jiu as well as that of their functions as conditional and concessive conjunctions. Based on the historical developments of the three words, this paper argues that all the three conjunctive functions of the three words were grammaticalized from the emphatic adverbs. This paper also discusses the parallel grammaticalization in other languages and the conditions and mechanisms for the grammaticalization in Chinese.
Chang,Li-li

5

The Bodily Subjectivity in the Touching: Maurice Merleau-Ponty and Michel Henry

This paper discusses the problem of bodily subjectivity via an analysis of touch, in order to distinguish two models in phenomenology: Maurice Merleau-Ponty (1908-1961) as the model of hetero-affection and Michel Henry (1922-2002) as the model of self-affection. The first section traces the subtle difference of the problem of touching in Merleau-Ponty. In his earlier works, due to the idea of reflexivity, body and world are understood through the perspective of co-naturality; the concept of reversibility is deduced from the tactile reflexivity in later works. In regards to self-touching, reversibility implies a reflexivity that includes others, leaving the tactile body open to them. Merleau-Ponty refers to this phenomenon as divergence. On the contrary, what Henry emphasizes is the irreducible subjectivity in bodily affection. There is no priority in touching for Henry; rather, through analysis of touching, the immanence and initiative of the body is revealed. The affective immanence taking place in the body designates the essence of manifestation, or the essence of phenomenon. The model for this is self-affection ad self-proof. What makes this self-proof possible is the manifestation of life, so that, the bodily affection is the self-manifestation of life. By way of contrasting these two models, we can better understand the subtle nuances in the analysis of bodily feeling, grasp the different possibilities of phenomenology, and further consider the problem of body and life in the present age.?
Huang, Kuan-min

6

Schizo-analysis of Michel Foucault: Trespassing in the Dispositif of Literature

Michel Foucault’s dispositif of literature contains two essential concepts: trespassing and folding. They are the most unique aspects of his thought and correlate with inverse archeology and inherent genealogy, respectively. This article builds on the foundation of previous research done on the topic, highlighting the strange relation between trespassing and boundaries, which characterizes its own temporality. Trespassing, and particularly the alternate space-time that it represents, is the basic most concept in understanding Foucault’s thought. It could even be argued that it is the transcendent field where all problems originate and develop. Without the mindset of boundaries, as is shown through trespassing, Foucault’s well-known archeology and genealogy would be stripped of their philosophical implications and be reduced to mere empirical laws.
Yang, Kai-lin

7

Poetry on Tea by Tang Monks

While tea meditation was popular during the Tang dynasty, extant prose from this period contains no mention of it. There are only a few statements that can be found in written rules for Buddhist monasteries. However, Tang poetry provides a possible look into the form and extent of tea culture at this period in history.
This paper analyzes a total of 131 poems on tea written by 30 different monks. It is found that tea culture had spread to virtually every monastery in the Tang. Not only did monks meditate while drink tea, they also presented it as an offering to Buddha. Monks and men of letters traditionally interacted via prosaic and poetic compositions. During this time, tea also became a medium by which the two different groups came together, resulting in the prevailing custom of tea parties. These provide insights into the interaction between monks and the outside world, as well as why and how tea became a part of meditation.

Hsiao, Li-Hua
Editing Committee Office of Humanitas Taiwanica,
College of Liberal Arts, National Taiwan University
No. 1, Sec. 4, Roosevelt Road, Taipei, 106319 Taiwan Tel: +886-2-33663820   Fax: +886-2-23632164   E-mail:
bcla@ntu.edu.tw