News Introduction Editorial Board Submission Table of Contents Table of Contents E-Journals Search
Humanitas Taiwanica, No. 68
Item
Title
Author

1

The Yin Calendar in Qishi’s Theory of Wuji: With an Explanation of the Six Emotions Divination in the “Biography of Yi Feng”


According to the theory of Wuji : “Mao (卯) is “Tian Bao” (天保); You (酉) is “Qi Fu” (祈父); Wu (午) is “Cai Qi” (采芑); Hai (亥) is “Da Ming” (大明).” However, scholars’ explanation for this classification method is unclear. This paper asserts that the basis of the classification method is the Yin calendar (殷曆).
First, what Wuji proclaims also appears in the “Biography of Yi Feng” in Han History and in “Fanlishu” in Shi Wei (詩緯.汎歷樞), in which the calendar used is most likely the Yin calendar.
Second, according to Meng Kang, the term “Wuji” in the “Biography of Yi Feng” signifies the year ying and yang intersected. This means that the terrestrial branches of Wuji could be the name of a year.
Third, according to “Qianzaodu” in Yi Wei (易緯.乾鑿度), King Wen of the Zhou Dynasty was enthroned in the year Wuwu (戊午蔀) 29th. The ancient history recorded in “Ji Lan Tu” (稽覽圖) used the Yin calendar and states that the year King Cheng was enthroned should be Dinghai (丁亥). This is in conformity with the statement that “Hai is “Da Ming”” and proves that Meng Kang’s explanation is correct.
Fourth, Wuji also states: “Xu (戌) is “The Crossing of October”.” “The Crossing of October” cited in the “Biography of Yi Feng” coincides with the Jiaxu (甲戌) year of the Emperor Yuan in the Han dynasty. Therefore, the terrestrial branches of Wuji possibly represent the names of the years. The poems can be aligned with various years of the Zhou dynasty. However, due to a lack of documentation, some terrestrial branches could not be correlated to specific years.
This paper also provides an explanation of the Six Emotions divination in the “Biography of Yi Feng”.

Gao, Ji-yi

2

An Analytical Investigation into the Relationship between the Law and Revenge from the Han Dynasty to the Southern and Northern Dynasties


Filial piety, as the core value of Confucian ethics, is readily transposed into an ethics of loyalty: that is, obedience to one’s master as opposed to obedience to one’s father. In theory, these two lines of loyalty should not be in conflict with each other. However, revenge, a principle based on filial piety, inevitably conflicts with law and justice, a sphere dominated by loyalty.
In the light of this conflict between loyalty to the law and filial piety, this paper looks at changes in traditional views toward revenge from the Han dynasty to the Southern and Northern Dynasties. While revenge was given precedence during the Han dynasty, the rulers of the Wei dynasty enacted laws curbing the act of revenge in order to enforce the state monopoly on violence. During the Northern and Southern Dynasties, a tolerant, even positive attitude towards revenge dominated in the south, while in the north loyalty to law was placed above filial piety and laws were put in place prohibiting acts of revenge.

Lee, Long-shien

3

A Study on the Characteristics of Personal Pronoun Usage in Poems of Cao Pi and Cao Zhi: Reviewing the Theory of “Suppress Cao Pi and Exalt Cao Zhi” from the Perspective of Choice and Use of Personal Pronouns in “Character Representation” Poems


The usage of the Chinese personal pronoun has always been an important issue that has received considerable attention from scholars in the field of the Chinese grammar. This essay explores personal pronouns in poems written by Cao Pi and Cao Zhi and discusses their usage primarily by examining the structure of their poems, an approach which from traditional grammatical analysis.
Personal pronouns appear in over half of Cao Pi’s and Cao Zhi’s extant poems. Several poems use more than one personal pronoun. One reason for this may lie in the face that their poems belong mainly to either yuefu or the ancient style of poetry and they were influenced by folk songs and the vernacular. Actually, the two poets didn’t only mimic former styles, they also created new stylistic features that relate to the thought and expression of themselves as authors, the artistic features in the structure of the poems, and readers’ explanation and evaluation of the poems.
This essay discusses several poems in which specific personal pronouns were used and focuses on their usage. Moreover, it seeks to identify the similarities and differences between the two brothers’ poems. It is hoped that this essay will contribute to our understanding of the relationship between the two brothers and their poetry.

Lee, Hsi-chen

4

The Interplay between Classical Chinese Prose and Fiction in the Tang Dynasty: A Study of Works by Han Yu and Liu Zongyuan


The interplay between classical Chinese prose and fiction during the Tang dynasty has long been a point of interest in Chinese literary history. This paper will first review literature on this topic by earlier scholars. Then it will go on to look at works by Han Yu (韓愈) and Liu Zongyuan (柳宗元)—two authors who have historically moved between classical Chinese prose and fiction—from three different perspectives in order to reveal the interplay with fiction seen in their prose. The relationship between the works of Han and Liu and Tang dynasty fiction is first to be seen in their common source in a historical/biographical tradition, with the specific nature of their interaction in this respect manifesting in the form of their fantastic, satirical style. Next, looking at the authorial intent of both Han and Liu, we can see that their use, in this particular vein of writing, of characters existing at the margins of society and anthropomorphized objects was in fact an intentional ploy to express their disappointment with and views on the world. This approach is both consistent with the traditional view of fiction as “having some value despite being of the small Way (小道)” and can be seen as a conceptual elevation of this kind of fantastic, satirical writing to the same level as the classics, history, and poetry. This in turn served to influence the self-awareness in later fictional creations and foment a bi-directional interaction on the notions of fictional creation. From this discussion, we will be able to see clearly that both Han and Liu employed the intent, contents and form of fictional narrative when writing their classical prose. In doing so, they expanded the range of artistic expression for classical prose as a literary form even as their writing served to nurture the production of fiction.
Kang, Yun-mei

5

The Basic Characteristics of Zhu Xi’s Worldview


Zhu Xi’s worldview has four basic characteristics: a “this-worldly” monism, cyclic evolution, organicism, and belief in cosmic principle (tian li). These attributes are closely related and must be considered as a whole, although each individually implies an entire set of secondary concepts and ideas. The canon of “this-worldly” monism is integrated with Zhu’s idea of holism, his belief that everything is an inseparable unity and originates from the same “dynamic element” — qi (energy/matter). It also means naturalism, natural deities and ghosts, the unity of the sacred and the secular, the unity of nature and humanities, intra-subjectivity, the unity of mind and matter, the unity of yin and yang (negative and positive aspect of the same “dynamic element” qi) and the unity of the five phases (wu-xing) all represent different but corresponding aspects of this “dynamic element.” The canon of cyclic evolution implies a worldview of “becoming,” a process philosophy that includes a belief in equilibrated and universal tenets. It also means the cyclic evolution of yin and yang and the five phases, and the spontaneity of the evolution and creation of nature. The canon of organicism indicates a kind of “life philosophy,” a belief that everything is a part of one body, as well as belief in concepts such as the “direct correspondence” between heaven and man, the unity of heaven and man, and the mind of heaven and earth. The belief in cosmic principle implies disenchantment, rationalization under evolutionary principles, a return to basic principles, the sagely nature of humanity and the cosmos, the inseparability of principle and qi, as well as the ideas that heaven is the principle, “nature/essence” is the principle, and the No Ultimate (wuji) gives birth to the Supreme Ultimate (Taiji). It also means the oneness of nature/essence and function, and the priority of principle to qi. In sum, the world in Zhu Xi’s mind is an organic entity that evolves according to cosmic principles in a cyclic way.
Wu, Chan-liang

6

Manipulating Kingship Discourse: Henry VIII’s New Historical Interpretation of Ancient Kingship


This paper deals with the kingship propaganda promoted by Henry VIII during the English Reformation. Reformation caused an unprecedented crisis for King Henry. He had to explain his expansion of kingship to win back the support of his people, which was crucial to the survival of his regime. He reinterpreted ancient kingship to build a foundation for his own kingship. However, his interpretation of King David and King John shows that he did not mean to clarify the essence of kingship, but rather to take these examples as immediate evidences to validate his own kingship. Henry was pursuing a propaganda campaign. The conclusion of this paper will contribute to the debates of Tudor political history and English Reformation.
Lee, Juo-yung

7

Performing Mother Power in Coriolanus: Shakespeare’s Volumnia and Her Afterlives on Stage


Volumnia cuts a striking figure in the gallery of Shakespearean mothers. Although the plot of Coriolanus follows closely Plutarch’s Lives of the Noble Grecians and Romans, the effects Shakespeare aims at in this play seem to go far beyond political morality lessons expounded by the sources. The play’s ambiguity on the political, ethical and philosophical levels, as Jan Kott puts it, makes it a great hall of mirrors, where no clear-cut moral lessons can be expected. This distinctive ambiguity could be hard to swallow, like “caviar to the common taste.” Although Coriolanus has long been deemed difficult and, compared with other Shakespearean tragedies in the canon, its reception at the box office has remained relatively cold, critics today have largely agreed to read the way Shakespeare impassively withholds explanation as signature touches of the play’s virtuosic design.
This paper attempts to scrutinize the complex picture Shakespeare paints of Volumnia in this play and contemplate the challenges the role poses for the stage. Although she has implanted clear-cut ideas in her son—from which he cannot emancipate himself, she remains enigmatic in her innermost being, leaving much unsaid. As a dangerous woman who destroys the man she loves, she is all the more frightening for being a mother, who is supposed to be the source of nurture and life. Shakespeare’s bold characterization of the Roman mother is not for the faint-hearted and has put generations of actresses to the test.
Taking a good look at Shakespeare’s adaptations of his sources, the first part of the paper clarifies how Shakespeare colors this extraordinarily powerful mother with disturbing, darker shades after expanding the role Volumnia plays for the Coriolanus story. The second part of the paper reviews the play’s early performance history and illustrates how Coriolanus productions before the twentieth century sought to dispel the threatening elements of the Roman mother by textual surgery or other cosmetic treatments. The third part of the paper highlights the most notable Coriolanus productions after the twentieth century and examines different types of strategies employed for the stage interpretation of Volumnia. The wealth of performance data surveyed here should bring into relief the open nature of Shakespeare’s text, how it encourages interpretations of different emphases, and how hard it is to hope for a fully gratifying stage realization of a character like Volumnia.

Hsieh, Chun-pai
Editing Committee Office of Humanitas Taiwanica,
College of Liberal Arts, National Taiwan University
No. 1, Sec. 4, Roosevelt Road, Taipei, 106319 Taiwan Tel: +886-2-33663820   Fax: +886-2-23632164   E-mail:
bcla@ntu.edu.tw