News Introduction Editorial Board Submission Table of Contents Table of Contents E-Journals Search
Humanitas Taiwanica, No. 67
Item
Title
Author

1

Taoist Philosophical Naturalism and the Culture of Chu


This paper argues that the Taoist tradition of philosophical naturalism was an indigenous outgrowth of the southern culture of Chu, thus disputing the long-lived legend about its founder, Lao Dan, being steeped in the learning of Zhou in the north. Its development is seen as a humanistic movement charting a course of distinctive philosophical wisdom, steering clear of the Scylla of archaic religiosity and the Charybdis of Confucian moralism.
Kuang Mei

2

Wuse (物色): An Important Critical Concept of the Chinese Lyric Tradition


This paper attempts to explore the formation of the term wuse (物色, the appearances of things) as a concept of literary theory, which first appeared in Liu Xie’s Wen Xin Diao Long (文心雕龍). For a long time, critics have confused the concepts of wuse and ganwu (感物, stirring-and-response), and overlooked the important role that wuse played in the development of the Chinese lyric tradition. By comparing ways of looking at scenery and poets’ attitude towards scenery in ganwu poetry and landscape poetry, the paper tries to make a distinction between these two critical concepts. Furthermore, by tracing the use of the word se (色) in ancient literature, the author finds that Buddhist Phenomenalism seems to have triggered the sense of “scenery” in this word. The paper analyzes the relationship between this sense of “scenery” in se and the concept of wuse, and demonstrates the significance of the concept of wuse in Chinese literary criticism.
Zhang, Jing

3

A Chronological and Political Analysis of Han Yu’s “In Praise of Zi Chan’s Preserving Local Schools”


There have been various theories on when and why Han Yu wrote “In Praise of Zi Chan’s Preserving Local Schools.” This paper attempts to answer these questions by examining historical records, Han Yu’s poems, and the social and political background of his time. The reign of Emperor De of the Tang dynasty was known for “turning a deaf ear to the ills of the times,” “dictatorial rule,” and “indifference to problems of the people.” This and other facts suggest the date of authorship to be between the year Zhenyuan eleven (A.D. 795) and Zhenyuan 20 (A.D. 804), with the most likely time being the winter of Zhenyuan 15 (A.D. 799) or slightly thereafter. Not long before then, the students of the Imperial College beseeched the emperor to retain the wise Yang Cheng as prime minister. It was also then that Han Yu went to the capital to convey New Year felicities on behalf of the governor of Xuzhou. He witnessed the government’s high-handed suppression of public opinion and felt deeply saddened that the emperor not only failed to listen to the vox populi, but also failed to retain Yang Cheng. This is most likely why he praised the wise ruler during the Chun-Qiu Period, Zi Chan, as “a model leader.” He mentions Zi Chan’s preserving local schools and respecting elders (both being sources of public opinion), inviting advice, and the evil King Li’s censorship of public opinion in the Zhou dynasty. It is clear that he wrote in order to urge Emperor De to reverse his policy. Han Yu’s purpose was definitely more than the promotion of education. He also meant to admonish the emperor, satirize the succeeding prime minister, venerate the former one, and maybe even commemorate Lu Zhi.
Fang, Chieh

4

Textual Research on the Original Characters of Chinese Dialects and Ancient Chinese Lianmian Doublets


This paper discusses the phenomenon of original characters for terms in Chinese dialects also appearing as one of the characters in lianmian doublets in Ancient Chinese. First, we show that the character dong (?I or懂) in the lianmian (聯綿) doublet meng-dong (懵?I, with the second character sometimes appearing as 懂) is rarely used independently. We argue that dong in Ancient Chinese (with meanings of “a muddled mind” and “to understand”) and in Chinese dialects (with meanings of “muddled mind,” “slow-witted,” “not thought out,” and “rashly done”) are in fact the same word with two opposite meanings. Next, we discuss the term paizi ( 子, cripple), which is common to southern dialects. We argue that the original character for pai was not the second character in the lianmian doublet jibai (蹟 ). Rather, we show that it corresponds to the character bo ( (?J)) from the Middle Chinese gege (歌戈) rhymes, as this word and many others from this rhyme are pronounced with the vowel “ai” in the vernacular pronunciations of southern dialects and are cognate with the word bo (跛) in a number of dialects. As these two examples show, of the two words making up lianmian doublets in Ancient Chinese, at least one of which, while not being able to be used independently in the koine, could be used alone in Chinese dialects. Also, the two words making up lianmian doublets in dialects could be used with a certain degree of freedom, sometimes combining to make up rhyming two-syllable words. From this we can derive a methodology for finding the original characters for words in Chinese dialects. First, one should determine which rhymes, or endings, the words would most likely have and then search for the original character within that scope. If the original character is the one that appears in a lianmian doublets, it would be best to give at least one example of the character being used alone. It would also strengthen the argument to show that the character has cognates in other dialects. Finally, we point out that future research in this area should take into consideration lianmian doublets in both Ancient Chinese and dialects and rhyming two syllable words, with particular attention being paid to whether they have undergone the process of lexicalization, how the two words making up the doublet are used, and the stability of initial series (the motivation for meaning).
Hsu, Fang-min

5

The Early Qing Political Process and the Historical Significance of Regulating Immigrants Domicile Registration in Taiwan


Early Qing policies on the governance of Taiwan has been regarded as a important issue for nearly one hundred years, ever since In? Yoshinori first started researching it. Since then, similar studies have emerged massively; however, scholars rarely examine the practical issues regarding the domicile of Han immigrants from South China to Taiwan and how the administration of those areas from which inhabitants had left influenced policies on the governance of Taiwan. In Kangxi 51 (1712), the first regulation of immigrants domicile registration in Taiwan was recorded in Qing huidian shili (Qing Institutions and Laws). Discussing this regulation would allow us to re-establish how Qing administration processed the regulation and thus ascertain its historical significance. The regulation of immigrants domicile instituted between Kangxi 50-59 resulted from attempts by Qing Administration to regularize Taiwan society, which had been transformed by the influx of immigrants and plain cultivating at the same time, some thirty years after Qing took control of Taiwan in Kangxi 22 (1683). Meanwhile, a group of bureaucratic magistrates and local elites in the Fujian Zhangpu territory were influential in Taiwan affairs and policies, even though they were not directly involved in the governing of Taiwan. Different from the mainstream policies, their insight on Taiwan influenced Taiwan affairs from the Zhu Yigui Rebellion in late Kangxi period, up to the Yongzheng period.
Li, Wen-liang

6

The Harmony of the Soul


It is often held by scholars that Plato’s notion of the tripartite soul makes him unable to give an account of the unified soul or personality. The aim of this paper is to tackle this problem by proposing the following three views: first, Plato’s account of the soul would not commit him to the view that within the each part of the soul there are sub-divisions; second, the unity and harmony of the soul could not be achieved by violence and conversation, but by education. Finally, by exploring Plato’s education programme in The Republic we can see that it is the only efficient means for bringing the three parts into harmony, and makes them one instead of many
Hsu, Hsei-yung

7

History as the History of Thought: The Meaning and Limitation of Collingwood’s Thesis


Collingwood’s famous statement that all history is the history of thought is analyzed in this paper. It is argued that, for Collingwood, to understand history is to re-enact the historical agent’s thought; that is, the valid practical reasoning through which the agent determines his actions. As a consequence, some states of affairs that are generally regarded as objects of the historical narrative are thereby excluded from the horizon of historical understanding.
Shi, Weimin

8

The Mythos of a Sinologist: On the Self-image of Peter Kien in Canetti’s Die Blendung


This article focuses on the protagonist Peter Kien in Elias Canetti’s novel Die Blendung (Auto da fe) and aims at analyzing his title “the First Sinologist.” Through a detailed examination of his so-called “academic accomplishments,” this article proves that his “academic status” established in the novel is not objective information from the narrator about the fictional world, but megalomania (Grosenwahn) of Peter Kien self. By explaining the historical background and psychological factors behind this figure’s becoming a sinologist, this article hereby indicates that the traditional interpretation of the history of ideas (Geistesgeschichte), which sees Peter Kien as an archetype of the intellectual, has a blind spot.
Chang, Yau-chin

9

English-Only/Official vs. Bilingual Education/Bilingualism: A Critical Examination of Language Policy and Language Planning in the United States


Linguistic diversity, a phenomenon that has existed in the United States since the beginning of its history as a nation, has become a highly contentious issue in recent decades. As a result of the continuous controversies over English-only/Official vs. bilingual education/bilingualism, language policy and planning have often come to the forefront of political debates in the United States. This paper critically examines U.S. language controversies within several dominant theoretical frameworks of language planning and policy. The examination indicates that under the tremendous impact of the dominant language-as-problem orientation, standard English, and English monolingualism, U.S. language policy is largely restrictive in nature, and heavily encumbered by politics and ideology. The real agendas underlying the language policy debates of the early 21st century are not about language per se; rather, they are more about immigration. Specifically, the source of language controversies lies in the more fundamental problems regarding social stratification and inter-ethnic competition, rather than the increased language diversity in the contemporary American society. This paper concludes with several proposed avenues to shape a more supportive and positive language policy in the U.S..
Hsu, Wen-hsien
Editing Committee Office of Humanitas Taiwanica,
College of Liberal Arts, National Taiwan University
No. 1, Sec. 4, Roosevelt Road, Taipei, 106319 Taiwan Tel: +886-2-33663820   Fax: +886-2-23632164   E-mail:
bcla@ntu.edu.tw