News Introduction Editorial Board Submission Table of Contents Table of Contents E-Journals Search
Humanitas Taiwanica, No. 65
Item
Title
Author
1
From Shi-yi Constructions to Conditionals

This paper discusses the grammatical transformation of Chinese Shi-yi verbs into both conditional conjunctions and concessive conditional conjunctions, which are respectively exemplified by the historical developments of the requesting verbs shi (使) and ling (令) and the letting verbs rao (饒) and ren (任).
The first part of this paper focuses on the processes, conditions and mechanisms for the two paths of grammatical transformation. It argues that the mechanism for the first grammatical transformation is metonymy, whereas the second is metaphor. By comparison with other conditionals and concessive conditionals, this paper also demonstrates that the conditionals derived from Shi-yi constructions have the characteristic of being “counterfactual,” whereas the concessive conditionals derived from Shi-yi constructions have the characteristic of being “contrastive.”
The second part of this paper focuses on cross-linguistic comparison. The parallel development of the Greek as is introduced to show that the grammaticalization discussed in this paper is not unique to Chinese. The conditions and mechanisms of the grammaticalization of as proposed by Nikiforidou (1996) can also be used to support the analysis in this paper. Finally, this paper points out that the two paths of grammaticalization are from parataxis to hypotaxis, similar to the cline of clause-combining constructions proposed by Hopper and Traugott (2003 [1993]).

Chang, Li-li
2
A Study on the Yiyang Opera and Its Later Divisions

The Yiyang opera became popular at least by the early part of the Ming dynasty (early 15th century). The scope of its circulation included such areas as Jiangxi, Anhui, the Northern and Southern capitals, Hunan, Fujian, Guangdong, Yunnan, and Guizhou. The magnitude of its influence made it the top operatic style in the Jiajing period (1522-1566). The earliest recording of Yiyang style operas can be found in Zhu Yunming’s Weitan (Indecent Talk), which was written during the Zhengde period (1506-1521). At that time, Yiyang opera was on the same par with the Yuyao, Haiyan, and Kunshan styles. Its wide circulation is most likely a result of the special nature of its tunes and the fact that many of the early operas written in this style were well preserved. These early recorded pieces incorporated ballads from “the lanes and alleys” and villages tunes, and used gongs and drums to keep rhythm. They also drew from northern arias, creating “rolling dialog” (gunbai) and “rolling songs” (gunchang), which paved the way for even further creative development in the later Qingyang tunes.
After the Wanli period (1573-1620), Yiyang opera started being recorded much more extensively. During the Qianlong period (1736-1796) of the Qing dynasty, the name Yiyang was changed to Gao. Written records of Gao opera can be found up to the Daoguang period (1821-1851). Many other styles were offshoots from Yiyang opera, including Huizhou, Siping, Qingyang, Huichi Elegant tune, as well as Peking opera. Even today, many of its characteristics can be found in Jiangxi Guju opera, Zhejiang Wuju opera, Fujian drama, and Standard Cantonese drama. A look at its composition and circulation will reveal that Yiyang opera enjoyed the widest circulation out of the five main operas of the Ming dynasty, enchanted people with its use of common speech and “noisy” tunes, and was loved by the widest segment of the population. Because of this, it had long been the envy of the Kunshan Shuimo tune, which was advocated by Ming literati but could never seem to overtake Yiyang opera in popularity.

Tseng, Yong-yih
3
Reflections on the Gardens and the Historical Meanings of Writings on Derelict Gardens in the Qing Dynasty

The Garden Literature of the Qing dynasty generally follows the content, style and features of traditional garden literature, while at the same time adding unique modes of expression, among which writings on derelict gardens is the most distinguished. Following the great prosperity of the Song and Ming dynasties, a large corpus of poetry and literary works written on derelict gardens began to appear in the Qing dynasty. This paper first explains the phenomenon of leisure activities undertaken in the derelict gardens often seen in the Qing dynasty, and then analyzes the reasons why derelict gardens were visited. Based on this background, the physical outlook in derelict garden writings is discussed for a reflection on the corresponding relationships between the key elements of the garden, nature and humanity. Furthermore, the sentimental themes in these writings are analyzed, and the philosophic theories and the structure of the theme of recalling antiquity are explained. This paper further investigates and analyzes the strong derelict consciousness often expressed in the garden literature of the time. Evers when a garden was at peak, the literati often would anticipate its future dilapidation. They took great pains to record the history of the gardens and the process of dilapidation, revealing the latent feelings of impermanence and of the derelict consciousness in the literati of the Qing dynasty. Finally the paper summarizes the meanings implied by derelict garden writing, including the conscious reflections on the essential meaning of the gardens, and the historical meanings of the development of the gardens.
Hou, Nai-huei
4
The Shift of “Bartering the Body for the Soul”: The Physique, Spirit, and National Identity of Characters in Lu Xun’s Novels

This article discusses the strategies of representation in Lu Xun’s novels, as well as the shifts in cultural tradition that underlie these modes of writing. It takes as its starting point the “physique” (tige) and the “spirit” (jingshen) that pervade so many of Lu Xun’s narratives, and asks what kind of “body” Lu chose as representative of the Chinese. The article further inquires the function of the “spiritual/physical” in the structure of the narratives, the reasons for them, and Lu Xun’s creative adaptation and rewriting of the (national) body theme—a theme that has appeared in the late Qing. That is: how does the “spirit/body” duality find expression in his novels, and how does he appropriate the “physical” and the “spiritual” in these narratives? Finally, the article assesses the strategies employed by Lu Xun for the representation of national identity, as seen from the “physical” and “spiritual” outlook of the characters in his novels.
Guan, Kean-fung
5
A Comparative Study of “Golden Lock Notes” and A Grumbling Maid

This paper compares two works of Eileen Chang (Zhang Ailing): her early novelette “Golden Lock Notes” and its later version as the novel A Grumbling Maid. Many differences can be identified between them, with potentially significant implications. For example, with respect to characterization, does the hero, Lord Third, change from a decent and cautious person in “Golden Lock Notes” to a mean and frivolous guy in A Grumbling Maid? Or would it be more accurate to say that the portrayal of the character in the later version is more realistic and truer to life, just like the heroine herself? Is the character rounder or more typical as a result of this change? Also, the character of Jiang Changan, daughter of Cao Qiqiao, does not appear in A Grumbling Maid. Why, and what is the influence of her disappearance? From the viewpoint of structure, if A Grumbling Maid is meant to be cyclical, does this imply that the tragic ending is the inescapable fate of traditional and modern women alike? Finally, in terms of style, with the later version loving more descriptions of historical background, a less dramatic plot, and simple and natural writing, can it be concluded that Chang wrote this novel in a more modern way?
Kuo, Yuh-wen
6
The Dispute between Mainland Presidents and Native Intellectuals at NTU in the Early Retrocession Period (1945-50)

When the Japanese surrendered in 1945, China recovered its lost land—Taiwan—from Japan. Unfortunately, some serious conflicts resulted from this between mainlanders and Taiwan natives. This paper explores the disputes between mainland presidents and Taiwanese intellectual figures at NTU.
The university has had four mainland presidents: Lo Song-lo (羅宗洛), Lu Chih-houng (陸志鴻), Zuang Chang-Kong (莊長恭) and Fu Ssu-nien (傅斯年). Lo took over the university right after the retrocession and initiated reforms. He retained some local faculty members from Taihoku Imperial University, of which Tu Chung-ming (杜聰明) was the most famous (Professor Tu was appointed dean of the Medical School). Lo also invited many outstanding local intellectual leaders to work at the new university, the most notable being Professor Lin Mou-sheng (林茂生), who was made a member of the succession team and bore the responsibility of heading the College of Liberal Arts and Political Science. From then on, Tu and Lin supported the various mainland presidents in their efforts to build up the new university. Gradually, however, disputes arose between the various mainland university presidents and the Taiwanese intellectuals. In the February 28th Incident, Professor Lin was arrested and was soon to be killed and Professor Tu resigned from his post.
Why was the cooperation between these mainland presidents and the local intellectuals unable to endure? This paper will attempt to answer this question through an examination of historical facts.

Lee, Tong-hwa
7
Staging Poetic Justice: Public Spectacle of Private Grief in the Musical Parade

This paper makes inquiries into the 1998 musical Parade by playwright Alfred Uhry and composer Jason Robert Brown, based on the historic case of Leo Frank, a Jewish industrialist from New York running a pencil factory in Atlanta and accused of murdering the 13-year-old girl Mary Phagan in 1913. How can the thorny case be represented with any fidelity on stage when all the facts have not come to light? What can a theatre researcher contribute to or comment on a controversial production of a reproduction of a historical incident that has never ceased to produce great furors over the past 90 years? In the absence of irrefutable legal evidence that could close the case and in the face of contending camps that claim justice on each side, the author will stay above the litigation fray and distance himself from any attempt to pass judgment on the innocence or guilt of people involved in the historic case. Rather, the paper first probes the context surrounding the case, including war, class, race, and to a lesser extent, sexuality by examining it from the perspective of historical legacy, such as the post-bellum South reeling from the repercussions of the Civil War defeat, the regional animosity between the highly industrialized North and New Industrial South, the class antagonism of management and labor in the pencil factory, the ethnic strife between blacks, whites, and Jews, and the conventional bias against the perceived sexual perversion of Jews and blacks.
Secondly, the paper discusses the embedded theatricality of both the national institution of trial by jury and the regional institution of lynching in the US. Then, it considers the staging of Frank’s trial, conviction, death penalty, commuted sentence and final lynching, each phase of the case presented as public spectacle. Musicals have been conventionally considered a genre that thrives on light-hearted sentimentality and fantasy, but its recourse to spectacle and appeal to emotion paradoxically lends itself to the heightened emotion of the conflicted victims in private as well as the specular nature of the trial and lynching in public, giving utterance to both the public outrage and private trauma.
The paper concludes that since vigilante justice takes over and continues the vicious cycle of vengeance where legal justice fails, poetic justice in the form of theatrical representation, albeit not without its problematics, should be rightfully taken into account as a viable means of redressing public wrong and representing private grief.

Wang, Pao-hsiang
8
Staging Eugene O’Neill in China in the 1980s

The 1980s, the decade right after the “Cultural Revolution,” witnessed a sudden surge of spoken-drama productions of Eugene O’Neill plays in Mainland China. These performances interacted with the political and cultural context of the time, producing a significant phenomenon in Chinese theater history that invites close examination. Most of the early productions of that decade showed propaganda and ideological propensities; they were supposedly realistic in style and faithful to the original script. Later efforts, however, expressed more humanist concerns and enlightenment values than socialist anxieties. Some turned from O’Neill’s realistic plays to his experimental pieces and others featured conscious subjectivity in the directors’ interpretation of O’Neill texts. The change also indicated a divergence in attitudes of different generations toward O’Neill. The eclectic American dramatist exerted a far-reaching influence on the Chinese theater of spoken drama throughout the 1980s and would continue to have his presence felt in the decades to come.
Zhu, Xue-feng, Liu, Hai-ping
Editing Committee Office of Humanitas Taiwanica,
College of Liberal Arts, National Taiwan University
No. 1, Sec. 4, Roosevelt Road, Taipei, 106319 Taiwan Tel: +886-2-33663820   Fax: +886-2-23632164   E-mail:
bcla@ntu.edu.tw