研討日期

2004年10月23日上午10:00 ~ 12:00

研討地點

台大社會科學院第2教室

討論文獻

題目

作者

文獻出處

Sequential Versus Simultaneous Choices with Endogenous Quality and Price

梁文榮、陳盈秀

Secondly Working Paper

報告人

陳盈秀

參加人員

黃鴻、邱俊榮、胡均立、王光正、吳世傑、楊雅博、邱郁秀、陳宏易、陳更生、吳芝文、許淑煐、王胤杰、梁文榮

討論提要

This manuscript employs a two-stage model, in which two firms sequentially choosing their quality levels in the first stage and then sequentially choosing prices in the second stage. The purpose of this manuscript is to compare the differences of the firms’ quality levels, prices, profits, consumers’ surplus and welfare among Motta (1993), Aoki and Prusa (1996) and this paper. The discussion focuses on how to explain the results with appropriate diagrams.

結論

1.      The high quality of this paper is in-between those of Motta (1993) and Aoki and Prusa (1996), while the low quality the highest.

2.      The prices of both low and high quality products in this paper are all the highest among the three papers.

3.      The profit of the high quality firm in this paper is the lowest, while that of the low quality firm is the highest. Moreover, the aggregate profit of this paper is the lowest.

4.      This paper proves that when the price leader has a quality advantage of choosing the quality level first, he will earn a higher profit than the price follower. This overturns the conventional wisdom that the price leader is always earning lower profit.

延伸研究

Dr. Hwang suggests two diagrams to explain the results derived in the paper.

備註